The Bounty – Review (Spoiler Free)

1984This review is part of Forgotten Film‘s 1984 blogathon. This blogathon is nice and simple, over 100 bloggers shall be covering films that were released in the year 1984. You can find out more details as well as the list of films covered here:

The Bounty posterWith its excellent performances and engaging moral dilemmas The Bounty is well worth your time.

This film has a fantastic cast with members that include Anthony Hopkins, Mel Gibson, Daniel Day Lewis, Bernard Hill, Laurence Olivier and Liam Neeson. Then again, this tale of mutiny at sea has always attracted strong actors such as Marlon Brando, Richard Harris, Clark Gable and Trevor Howard in previous versions of the story. What’s interesting here is that, unlike in earlier films where Lieutenant Bligh is portrayed as a monster, Hopkins here provides us with a man who is complex, but more importantly who is relatable.

For those who don’t know, the film follows the story of  a crew who set sail for the idyllic island of Tahiti. On their journey to paradise tensions rise between the crew and the increasingly harsh Lieutenant Bligh, a conflict which ultimately results in a mutiny. I’ll save the details of how the events all play out, after all I like to preserve spoilers on this site, but I will say that here we are not faced with a simple discussion of freedom versus dangerous authority but a far richer display of competing ideas of duty, life, what it means to be human and what ultimately is worth sacrificing one’s life for.

The Bounty Anthony HopkinsThe film’s greatest strength is undoubtedly Hopkins’ performance. In this blogathon which examines the year 1984, I will put forward the argument that his is one of the strongest and most exhilarating of those which the year produced. His character is undoubtedly flawed but, as easy as it is to get caught up in the marauders’ hatred of him, if you look closely you can see more kindness and loyalty in Bligh than in any other character. He does not overshadow his other cast members however; Gibson’s take on Fletcher Christian is a very quiet, meditative one. Some have criticised it as being vapid, but I think it is an intelligent take on the character which allows him to display a great range of skills when Fletcher is both forced into desperate action and in the more passionate moments his character finds. His silence also invites us in to think about how we would deal with the situation. We find ourselves working through the deliberations he deals with and ultimately opens the film up for us to ethically engage with its moral dilemmas.

For a film which does so much right it is a great shame that I have to list two prominent flaws. The first being the film’s pacing. It could have used a little tightening up in the middle. Although a few scenes do drag a little, it doesn’t ruin the film by any means. It just has to fight for your interest a little more than it should at times. The second flaw is much more troublesome, and that is its depiction of the natives the crew find. I was hoping that the crew’s dreams of finding a paradise full of sexually free and beautiful women would be met by a very different reality. With people rather than free sexual pleasures. If the natives aren’t being sexualised then they are either unintelligent or cannibalistic in nature, and that’s a great shame. Still, if you can look past that, and I could here, then you’ll find this to be a very well acted and an all round  entertaining adventure movie. The story may have been told endless times before, but this retelling justifies itself.


What is the film’s greatest strength? Anthony Hopkins’ complex and compelling performance.

Its greatest weakness? The treatment of the natives; both as simple sexual pleasures and cannibalistic savages.

Would I see it again? Yes, it’s a good adventure film with some great performances.

Fire out your thoughts in the comment box below!


  1. I didn’t even know there was a third version of Mutiny on the Bounty. Brando’s take is probably my favorite, but most people prefer the original. I’m not sure why. You should have compared the versions, but from your description, I’m not sure I want to see Mel Gibson trot around on a ship.

    1. I might compare them some day but the blogathon was just about reviewing the one film!

      I think it’s worth a look if you ever find yourself with a spare moment. Hopkins is fantastic!

  2. Depressing when someone gets over 100 people for a blogathon!! Haha, makes my new one look very unpopular 😉

    1. Haha well if it is any consolation I think it’s pretty rare to get so many people involved!

  3. The Bounty was one of the first DVDs I ever bought! It’s been so long that I forgot just how many famous faces are in this retelling. Both Hopkins and Gibson are uniquely commanding in their roles.

    1. Glad that you like them both here! I was really surprised at just how many famous and talented people kept on appearing on the screen!

  4. This is a great review! I love your writing and always enjoy your perspective.

    1. Why thank you, it’s nice to hear that from you!

  5. […] – It’s mutiny, I tell you! Mr. Rumsey’s Film Related Musings looks at The Bounty. […]

  6. It’s been years since I’ve seen this – but I remember enjoying it for the same reasons you articulate here (very well by the way). Time to add another movie to my Netflix list!

    1. Oh thank you!
      Let me know what you think when you catch up with it again.

  7. […] – It’s mutiny, I tell you! Mr. Rumsey’s Film Related Musings looks at The Bounty. […]

  8. The one drawback from a film making perspective, at least in my view, was the score. Why is Vangelis there doing electronic goth when a sea shanty or orchestral score might have made the film feel less portentous?

    1. Hmmm surprisingly the score wasn’t a problem for me. Then again I didn’t love it either.

      Do you like the movie otherwise?

  9. I’m another one who’s seen the two previous versions of “Mutiny”, but not this one. Sounds intriguing – and what a great cast! I will check it out!

    1. Yeah the cast is more than just a little impressive isn’t it! I hope you enjoy it when you see it.

Go ahead and leave a reply!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s